On Consent and Leprechaun games
I’ve been thinking a lot about consent recently. This link says it better than I can right now.
I’ve also been thinking about the subtler ways that people violate consent.
The violations that are so invisible to people who feel entitled to them that if you point them out, they get outraged. They belittle the fact that you expect to have a right to your own body, mock you for it, and often outright ignore your boundaries.
Exhibit A:
There’s a game I’ve seen people play. I bet you’ve seen it too. Hell, I bet most of you’ve played it.
It’s a game whose sole purpose is to see how far you can violate someone’s boundaries. It is predicated on making a person feel helpless, ignoring their protests just for your own amusement.
I call it “Oh, look. They’re blushing.”
Yes, this is the game when someone notices a blush and points it out. The person who is blushing (a sign that everyone clearly interprets as discomfort due to helplessness) protests. Asks people to stop.
“Oh, look! They’re getting redder!”“Aw how cute, they can’t help it!”
Sometimes, this is a group sport. Other people join in, mocking. Manipulating. Feeding off the powerlessness.
The game ends whenever the people with the power decide to stop.
Oh, but this is all in good fun, right? It’s just a game!I have a friend who says it’s okay.
I say it’s okay.
No matter how you rationalise it, this game violates consent. It is a power trip gotten from increasing someone’s helplessness. The “fun” is in ignoring the protests and continuing on.
Fuck.
This.
Why is this okay?
Just because everyone does it? Just because our culture tells us that it’s no big deal? (Of course, if you say it is, something must be wrong with you. You must not get it or can’t take a joke.)
Well, fuck your rape culture and traditions of violating boundaries.
Which brings us to…
Exhibit B
Today is St Patrick’s Day. A day often celebrated by getting piss-drunk and wearing green.
And of course, violating the consent of people who don’t.
Look, I know you’ve done this for ages. I know that your tradition tells you it’s not a big deal. It’s just pinching, and like, everyone knows that if they don’t wear green, they’re going to get pinched, yeah?
[They were asking for it, dressed like that.]
I don’t care.
You are still violating their consent.
It’s also really ethnocentric and fucked-up. The tradition of being pinched is an entirely American tradition from around the early 1700s. Apparently, wearing green would make you invisible to leprechauns, who would pinch anyone they could see. So people would pinch those not wearing green to remind them.
When I came to America, I had no idea about this. All I knew was that on one day in March, if I didn’t wear the colours mandated by the people around me, my body was considered their property to harm. Even when I learnt to wear green, it didn’t matter if they didn’t consider it “green enough”.
(Once in elementary school, when a classmate came up to me exclaimed “You’re not wearing green!”, I responded with “My underwear has green on it!”. It was apparently perfectly acceptable for him to say “Show me.” — or he would get free rein to pinch me the whole day. Luckily, the flowers on them were enough to placate him.)
And variations on this happen every year. Any protests of how fucked-up this tradition was would be met with scorn and ridicule.
Until finally, I had had enough.
One St Patrick’s day, I refused to wear green. Instead, I printed up a sign that said “If you pinch me, I will stab you with a rusty metal spoon. You have been forewarned.”
And sure enough, the first time someone pinched me, I pulled out a rusted metal spoon-like object from my purse and stabbed her with it. (Later research indicates that it might have been part of a vintage egg poacher. All I know is that I found it on the side of the road, and it was easy to wield.)
She walked away with a scar. So did the second person. The third person got stabbed, but no scar.
Eventually, people learned to keep their hands to themselves.
I find it sad that it actually had to get to the point of me retaliating for people to respect my boundaries.
If it’s just a game, why is the burden placed on the people who don’t want to play? If it’s just a game, take no for an answer.
So if you see me today, or any day for that matter, and you’re tempted to touch me without my consent, you can fuck right off.
I’ll take my chances with the leprechauns.
![Trigger warning for abuse:
I love Tangled, because it resonated a lot with me. A lot of the things Mother Gothel said to Rapunzel are things I’ve grown up with.
[looking in the mirror with Rapunzel] Mother Gothel: Look in that mirror. I see a strong, confident, beautiful young lady. [Rapunzel smiles] Mother Gothel: Oh look, you’re here too. [laughs] Mother Gothel: I’m just teasing! Stop taking everything so seriously.
This was nearly every conversation with my mother. Insults, back-handed compliments, verbal abuse…always followed with “Stop taking everything so seriously. It’s just a joke.”
Rapunzel: Hi. Welcome home, Mother. Mother Gothel: Oh! Rapunzel, how you manage to do that every single day, it looks absolutely exhausting, darling! Rapunzel: Oh, it’s nothing. Mother Gothel: Then I don’t know why it takes so long.
I grew up feeling like nothing I did was ever good enough. I grew up feeling like expecting any praise was foolish, selfish, and the desire for it made me a traitor to my culture.
Mother Gothel: You want me to be the bad guy? Fine. [Advances toward Rapunzel threateningly] Mother Gothel: Now I’m the bad guy…
I’m pretty sure that, like me, Rapunzel has some sort of BPD. I’d like to explore this in detail some day.
But not today. Introspection is hard, especially when it’s on topics hidden under years of painted smiles and secret memories. And sometimes it’s wise to take your remaining spoons and walk away.
Maybe, I’ll be able to explore this later. In the meantime, I’ll leave you with another secret.](http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lqi90tHd2n1r1wjsbo1_500.png)
